Reliable gland packing (compression packing) is one of the most cost-effective ways to control leakage, improve uptime, and meet environmental requirements in industrial fluid systems. Whether you’re sealing a pump shaft, agitator, or valve stem, the packing material you choose directly impacts:
sealing stability over time, sleeve/stem wear, heat generation and energy loss, chemical compatibility and safety, and fugitive emissions compliance. Among all packing materials, PTFE braided packing and graphite braided packing dominate high-performance applications—but they behave very differently in real equipment. This guide explains the “why” in plain engineering language and gives you a practical selection roadmap.
1) Why PTFE and Graphite Packing Became the “Post-Asbestos” Standards
As industries moved away from asbestos packing, two materials emerged as go-to solutions:
PTFE (Polytetrafluoroethylene) Packing
PTFE is known for its extreme chemical resistance and low friction. Its performance is largely driven by the strength of the carbon–fluorine (C–F) bond, one of the strongest in organic chemistry.
Typical PTFE advantages include: wide chemical compatibility (many acids, alkalis, solvents)
low friction for smoother operation and easier actuation
clean, non-contaminating options for food/pharma
Flexible Graphite Packing
Flexible graphite is made from expanded natural graphite and formed into dense rings or braided packing. Its layered crystal structure gives it:
excellent heat transfer
high-temperature stability (especially in steam)
strong performance in hydrocarbon and power-generation service
2) PTFE Gland Packing: Strengths and Real-World Limits
2.1 Low Friction (Great for Control Valves and Sleeve Protection)
PTFE typically runs with a very low friction coefficient, which helps reduce shaft/stem wear and improves controllability on actuated valves. DuPont data for PTFE lists very low static friction values (depending on counterface and conditions).
Where this matters most
control valves (lower hysteresis / smoother response)
applications where sleeve wear is expensive or frequent
2.2 Chemical Resistance Across Many Services
PTFE is widely used in chemical processing because it’s highly inert and resists a wide range of media.
Important practical note: even when PTFE is chemically stable, some gases or small molecules may permeate over time in certain packing constructions—so equipment corrosion risk should still be evaluated by service conditions.
2.3 Temperature and Heat Handling (The Hidden Weak Point)
PTFE is a poor heat conductor, and it expands significantly with temperature. That combination can increase running torque and raise “heat build-up” risk in higher-speed equipment. DuPont lists PTFE thermal conductivity around 0.25 W/m·K and a comparatively high thermal expansion coefficient.
Typical result in the field: PTFE packing is usually better for lower temperature / lower PV (pressure × velocity) duties. Higher-speed pumps often need flushing/cooling strategies if PTFE is used
3) Graphite Gland Packing: Why It Wins at High Temperature and High Speed
3.1 Heat Dissipation = Longer Life in Hot, Fast Equipment
Graphite’s biggest advantage is thermal management: it conducts friction heat away from the shaft/stem and into the stuffing box and body—helping prevent thermal runaway and extending sealing stability.
Where graphite excels: high-temperature steam valves; high-speed, high-duty pumps; hot hydrocarbons and refinery service
3.2 High-Temperature Stability (Especially in Steam)
Flexible graphite is widely used as a “default” packing material in steam and high-temperature systems. However, in air/oxygen, graphite can oxidize at elevated temperature; in steam, practical limits are often higher (depending on grade and inhibitors).
3.3 Watch-Out #1: Strong Oxidizers Can Destroy Graphite
Graphite is generally stable in many non-oxidizing services, but it’s not suitable for strong oxidizers (for example, high-concentration nitric acid or other highly oxidizing media). In those cases, PTFE is typically the safer direction.
3.4 Watch-Out #2: Galvanic Corrosion on Stainless Stems
Graphite is electrically conductive. In wet conditions, graphite in contact with stainless valve stems can contribute to galvanic corrosion risk. Many “low-emission” graphite packings address this using inhibitor technology (commonly including sacrificial-anode style additives).
4) Mechanical Behavior: “Cold Flow” vs. Resilience
PTFE: Cold Flow / Stress Relaxation
PTFE can creep under sustained compression load. Over time, bolt load relaxes and leakage may rise unless you re-tighten, use improved constructions, or apply live-loading hardware. (This is a key reason PTFE selection must consider maintenance strategy.)
Graphite: Better High-Temp Stability, but Needs Anti-Extrusion Design
Graphite generally holds up well under heat and can seal effectively, but braided graphite can extrude in high-pressure service unless reinforced. This is why high-performance packing sets often include:
reinforced end rings (anti-extrusion), dense die-formed graphite rings for sealing, composite braids for strength + lubricity
5) Fugitive Emissions and “Low-E” Packing: What Buyers Should Know
Environmental compliance has pushed many plants toward Low-E packing systems, often verified by industry standards.
API 622 is commonly referenced for packing type testing under controlled cycles and leakage measurement.
API 624 is commonly referenced as a valve-level test using packing qualified to API 622 (and checks the full stuffing-box system).
Practical takeaway:
Low emission sealing is rarely “just the packing.” It’s packing + stem finish + gland design + installation method + load control.
6) Practical Selection Guide: PTFE vs Graphite (and When to Use Composites)
Choose PTFE Braided Packing When You Need:
strong chemical resistance (especially where graphite is at risk)
clean/white packing for hygiene-driven industries, low friction on control valves,low-to-moderate temperatures (commonly under ~260°C continuous service range for PTFE), food-contact regulatory alignment (PTFE appears in U.S. FDA food-contact materials regulations under 21 CFR 177.1550—application-dependent)
Choose Graphite Gland Packing When You Need:
high-temperature steam sealing, fire-safe-oriented hydrocarbon services (equipment/fire-safe requirements drive material selection), high-speed pump duties where heat dissipation is critical, better thermal stability during frequent start/stop thermal cycling
Use Composite Packing When Conditions Are Mixed:
Graphite PTFE (often called “black PTFE packing”): improves wear/heat handling while keeping PTFE’s chemical stability direction.
Aramid corner-reinforced graphite packing: ideal for abrasive/solids service (slurries, ash, mining) where pure PTFE is too soft and pure graphite may extrude or wear faster
Buyer Advice: How to Avoid Common Packing Failures
Match gland packing to temperature AND PV, not just chemical compatibility
Control heat (flush plan, correct compression, proper sleeve finish)
Use the right gland packing set structure (end rings + sealing rings for high pressure / Low-E)
Plan for load stability (live loading is often a game-changer for long-term sealing)
Ask for compliance documentation when needed (FDA, Low-E test references, traceability)
Summary:
PTFE gland packing is the “chemical resistance + low friction” champion.
Graphite gland packing is the “high temperature + heat control” workhorse.
Plants that standardize on only one packing type usually pay for it later—in leakage, maintenance hours, sleeve damage, or compliance risk. A smarter approach is a simple decision matrix based on temperature, pressure, shaft/stem speed, and media—then selecting PTFE, graphite, or a proven graphite PTFE packing accordingly.
Leave A Comment